Showing posts with label Tech. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tech. Show all posts

Apr 22, 2017

Why Silicon Valley wants to thwart the grim reaper Why Silicon Valley wants to thwart the grim reaper Live forever: Scientists say they’ll extend life ‘well beyond 120’

‘In this world,” wrote Benjamin Franklin, “nothing can be said to be certain, except death and taxes.” This proposition doesn’t cut much ice in Silicon Valley, where they take a poor view of paying taxes. What’s interesting is that they are also coming to the view that perhaps death is optional too, at least for the very rich.

You think I jest? Well, meet Bill Maris, the founder and former CEO of Google Ventures, the investment arm of Alphabet, Google’s owners. Three years ago, Maris decided to create a company that will “solve” death. He pitched the idea to Google’s co-founders, Sergey Brin and Larry Page and, according to a lovely piece by Tad Friend in the New Yorker, Brin, who has a gene variant that predisposes him to Parkinson’s disease, loved the idea and Page declared that Google should do it.

Thus was born Calico, which is short for the California Life Company, in 2013. It started with a billion dollars in the bank and is “extremely secretive”. “All that’s known,” Friend writes, “is that it’s tracking 1,000 mice from birth to death to try to determine ‘biomarkers’ of ageing – biochemical substances whose levels predict morbidity; that it has a colony of naked mole rats, which live for 30 years and are amazingly ugly; and that it has invested in drugs that may prove helpful with diabetes and Alzheimer’s.”

Calico is a typical product of the reality distortion field that is Silicon Valley. It’s a salutary illustration of how sudden and unimaginable wealth can warp minds. There are people in Palo Alto, Mountain View and Cupertino who truly believe they are living in the Florence of Renaissance 2.0. Their religion is what Neil Postman called Technopoly and their prevailing mindset is what the technology critic Evgeny Morozov describes as “solutionism”, the belief that all problems __have technological solutions.

It turns out that death is now perceived as just such a “problem”. Friend quotes a hedge-fund manager waxing lyrical on this. “I __have the idea,” he burbles, “that ageing is plastic, that it’s encoded. If something is encoded, you can crack the code. If you can crack the code, you can hack the code!” Cue loud applause from the elite audience gathered in a Californian drawing room to discuss the secrets of longevity.

That’s not to say that longevity isn’t important or relevant. In most societies, people are living longer and that’s now giving rise to acute social, psychological and economic stress. Just ask anyone who works in the NHS. Dementia and Parkinson’s disease are laying waste to an increasing number of human minds, while heart disease, cancer and diabetes are making our bodies progressively enfeebled. We live longer but our closing years can be miserable, lonely and largely pointless.

To computer folk, DNA is just code, and code can always be hacked. Bingo! – immortality beckons

So it’s worth pouring resources into understanding and eventually curing these diseases. But the point of that is not to abolish death but to make the natural process of ageing more tolerable towards the end. And that’s what the majority of scientists and doctors are trying to achieve. They want us to have healthier lives and “compressed morbidity”, which is a polite term for a quick and painless death at the end.

The Silicon Valley crowd want something else, though: they seek to make death optional. And they think it can be done. After all, as some wag put it decades ago: “Death is nature’s way of telling you you’re fired.” Once we have mated and brought up some children, evolution regards us as disposable, past our sell-by date. So it has arranged that somewhere in our DNA are genes that will progressively trigger ageing processes, eventually causing our bodies to fail. To computer people, DNA is just code and code can always be hacked. So all we have to do is find the offending genes, edit them using Crispr and – bingo! – immortality beckons.

You have to marvel at the one-dimensionality of minds that can think like this. Apart from anything else, death is what gives meaning to life. It’s also the process that ensures human vitality: young people arrive with ideas that their elders never had and death makes room for them to grow, thrive and die in their turn. That’s why elite US universities, which do not have a retirement age for tenured professors, are increasingly desperate to find ways to incentivise them to quit.

Given that Silicon Valley billionaires are smart, they must know all this. So could it be that what underpins this strange new obsession with ensuring immortality is something more straightforward? Could it be that they all became wealthy at such a young age? So they have these unimaginable riches and have suddenly realised that they don’t have an infinite time to enjoy them. One’s heart bleeds for the poor lambs. Not.

Facebook purges tens of thousands of fake accounts to combat spam ring Facebook purges tens of thousands of fake accounts to combat spam ring Facebook killing video puts moderation policies under the microscope, again I've put my event on Facebook. Now how do I make sure people actually come?

Facebook has purged tens of thousands of fake accounts from its platform as part of an ongoing bid to dismantle a sophisticated global spam operation.

The worldwide crackdown on “inauthentic likes and comments” was launched on Friday and Facebook’s security team confirmed the step on Saturday in an official blog post attributed to Shabnam Shaik, a technical program manager, that said the platform had been working to disrupt a single network for six months.

Accounts appearing to be operated by people in Bangladesh, Indonesia, Saudi Arabia and “a number of other countries” that liked and commented on publishers’ pages were found to be “part of the same coordinated operation”, Shaik wrote.

The accounts had been created not en masse, but through “more sophisticated means” in an attempt to disguise the link between them. Proxies were used to disguise their true location.

“The apparent intent of the campaign was to deceptively gain new friend connections by liking and interacting primarily with popular publisher pages on our platform, after which point they would send spam.”

Most accounts had liked a number of publishers’ pages then been left dormant, Shaik wrote, “suggesting they had not been mobilised yet to actually make connections and send spam to those people.

“Our systems were able to identify a large portion of this illegitimate activity – and to remove a substantial number of inauthentic likes.”

The vast majority – Shaik gave the figure of 99% – of impacted pages with more than 10,000 likes would “see a drop of less than 3%”, she wrote.

“By disrupting the campaign now, we expect that we will prevent this network of spammers from reaching its end goal of sending inauthentic material to large numbers of people.”

Nearly 20,000 fake accounts that liked Guardian-branded pages on Facebook were removed, credited to “suspicious account removal”.

A spokeswoman for Facebook in Sydney said she was unable to give the total number of accounts removed globally.

Fake accounts are widely used to create and spread spam on Facebook, which is one of the reasons for the platform’s real-name policy.

Last week Shaik announced improvements to Facebook’s ability to detect even convincing fake accounts “by identifying patterns of activity – without assessing the content itself”.

Giveaways like the same content posted multiple times would be flagged to the platform through automated pattern-recognition.

“With these changes, we expect we will also reduce the spread of material generated through inauthentic activity, including spam, misinformation, or other deceptive content that is often shared by creators of fake accounts.”

The tens of thousands of accounts used by the spam operation were in addition to 30,000 French accounts suspended last week.

According to sources quoted by Reuters, those removals were motivated in part by the need to crack down on the spread of misinformation ahead of the hotly-contested presidential elections.

Call for fundraising pages to be regulated amid fraud concerns Call for fundraising pages to be regulated amid fraud concerns

It has become a familiar moment in the aftermath of any catastrophe – the appearance of a slew of online fundraising pages designed to funnel donations for the traumatised, injured and bereaved.

But after doubts were raised over some JustGiving pages launched in the aftermath of the Westminster attack, government ministers __have been urged to impose regulation – or face a growing risk of unscrupulous fraudsters taking advantage of tragedy.

David Clarke, the former director of the National Fraud Intelligence Bureau, said fundraising sites must do more to protect users. Clarke said: “Fraudsters are always looking for new ways to steal and launder dirty money and we must ensure this vital service for good is not open to abuse by criminals. Government must act quickly and decisively to protect the goodwill of our charitable citizens.”

The call for regulatory oversight comes after JustGiving took the unprecedented step of seizing control of a page that had raised £17,000 ostensibly set up in memory of Westminster victim Aysha Frade after donors noticed that the person who set up the page had the same name as a woman convicted of fraud.

About a dozen pages raising money for the victims’ families remain active on JustGiving, having raised close to £8,000 in total.

One of the pages was removed after concerns reported to JustGiving that it had used plagiarised text and was claiming to raise money for the UK charity HHUGS, which told the Guardian it had no connection to the page.

A JustGiving spokesman said there was “no way the page could be fraudulent” because any money raised would __have gone to the charity, rather than the individual who had set up the page. The site has said it would quarantine all money raised for the Westminster victims to ensure it reaches the intended beneficiaries.

In a separate case last week, a 32-year-old man was arrested on suspicion of fraud over a GoFundMe page that raised more than £20,000 following a petition to keep a police dog with its handler in Shropshire.

Concerns were raised when someone purporting to be a freelance journalist named Jacob Windsor set up a fundraising page and then linked a GoFundMe page to the Change.org petition set up by Jennie Evans, the daughter of retiring police officer David Evans.

The petition attracted more than 140,000 signatures and was supported by Angie Best, the ex-wife of George Best.

Anti-fraud experts have warned that scammers are increasingly finding it easy to exploit the rise in online giving on fundraising sites, which contribute significantly to the more than £2.4bn donated online annually in the UK.

But despite the growing popularity of sites such as JustGiving and GoFundMe, they do not face the same regulatory oversight as other charitable organisations.

The obvious body to oversee the sites would be the fundraising regulator, set up two years ago and chaired by the veteran television executive Michael Grade.

Yet a spokesman told the Guardian it was “not clear that commercial crowdfunding or giving platforms (which are commercial operations) fall within our remit which is first and foremost about fundraising by charities”.

The spokesman added that the regulator would assess whether JustGiving falls within its remit before deciding whether to investigate the fraud concerns following the Westminster attack.

There are concerns that social media has amplified the risk of cyber-fraud, particularly in cases when celebrities promote causes to their vast audience of followers.

A family run charity backed with millions of pounds by One Direction had its accounts frozen last week amid a Charity Commission and Metropolitan police investigation into the alleged misuse of funds.

Believe in Magic, co-founded by a mother and daughter after the daughter was diagnosed with a brain tumour, is being investigated following “multiple complaints” and “indications of misconduct or mismanagement”.

One Direction’s stars had been ambassadors for the charity, which had also reportedly received support from celebrities including Jessie J, Olly Murs, Pixie Lott, Little Mix, Professor Green, Fearne Cotton and Michael Bublé.

Clarke, the former head of the City of London police fraud squad and now director of the Fraud Advisory Panel, said it was surprising that fundraising sites fell outside the remit of the fundraising regulator.

He urged sites such as JustGiving to use sophisticated technology such as artificial intelligence and machine learning to combat fraud instead of relying on users to spot suspicious activity.

Clarke said: “I think we should be having more oversight and checking that they are implementing adequate counter-fraud procedures. If they are, then fine but we’ve got to have the oversight that they have adequate procedures to counter fraud.

“Are they doing that? It would appear that if we’re relying on users to report things being wrong, that’s not the use of big data analytics.”

A spokesman for JustGiving said the site was reviewing how it verifies fundraising pages in “moments of national crisis” following the concerns raised over the Westminster attack.

He added: “JustGiving has worked hard to ensure that all funds raised for the victims of the Westminster attacks reach the families, we are continuing to do so. While we have strong verification checks to ensure that people are who they say they are, we can’t verify people’s intentions.

“We rely on our community to raise any concerns they might have with our team who then have a clear investigation process.”

A spokesman for GoFundMe said misuse made up “less than one tenth of 1%” of all campaigns on the site. He said the site had “a number of layers of protection” and would soon offer a guarantee that donations reach the intended beneficiary or donors get their money back.

He added: “We have a team of experts across the world working round the clock to make sure donors, campaign organisers and beneficiaries are fully protected, bespoke technology monitoring for suspicious behaviour and over 25 million donors.

“When they see something they think might not be right, they tell us and our team looks into it and takes swift action.”

Online political advertising is a black box and democracy should be worried Online political advertising is a black box and democracy should be worried

As your mind wearily contemplates being exposed to yet another political campaign, are your dreams haunted by battle buses, billboards and TV debates? Or is it Facebook, YouTube, Twitter and Google?

On the evidence of last year’s EU referendum, much of the campaigning, and much of the money spent on political advertising, will be online. And it will happen in a way that will be largely hidden from scrutiny by either the public or regulators.

During the referendum, Vote Leave spent £2.7m with one small Canadian digital marketing firm that specialises in political campaigns – Aggregate IQ. The sum was well over a third of Vote Leave’s total budget.

Two other campaign groups – both of which received large donations from the Leave campaign - gave Aggregate IQ a further £765,000, taking the total pumped through the company to almost £3.5m. Vote Leave director Dominic Cummings is quoted on the company’s website saying “We couldn’t __have done it without them.”

Yet the invoices for the money they paid to Aggregate IQ, which were handed to the Electoral Commission, list vague jargon-filled specifications with little indication of how the ads were delivered. It may tell us Aggregate IQ were running a “targeted video app installed and display media campaign” but gives no clue about where those ads appeared or who saw them. Did most of the money go on Facebook or YouTube? Did they spend more money on reaching under 45s in Hull or pensioners in Canterbury? There’s no way of knowing, not least because the Electoral Commission doesn’t ask for the information.

Meanwhile Cambridge Analytica, the digital targeting experts part-owned by US billionaire Robert Mercer, were credited with super-charging the Leave.EU campaign, even getting a mention in a book about campaign by its chief funder Arron Banks. Yet according to filings with the Electoral Commission there was no paid relationship with the firm at all. The Electoral Commission is currently investigating, as is the Information Commissioner’s Office over the company’s use of data.

These two companies promise to sway the electorate using high-tech targeting of voters, yet not only does the Electoral Commission __have little idea of how the money is being spent, but many of the different messages those campaigns show chosen sets of targets are hidden from the rest of us.

An ad in a newspaper or magazine, a billboard or tube poster, can be seen by anybody who happens to come across it. They are targeted in a blunt way, by location, readership etc, but who they are appealing to, the messages used and the money spent is clear for all to see.

But online, ads are directed at far more specific target groups, and shown only to them. Suspect someone is a bit racist? Show them pictures of dark skinned migrants lining up at a border. Know someone regularly visits Spain? Emphasise how much longer it will take to go through airport security.

Just as importantly, you can make sure that you don’t show the wrong ads to the wrong people. The racist dog whistle doesn’t get pushed at people likely to be from, or comfortable with, ethnic minorities. The lengthy customs checks don’t get shown to those with an all-consuming fear of terror attacks.

Of course, people will see ads that aren’t aimed at them online – the targeting is far from perfect - but the digital world allows paid-for political campaigning to split into numerous conversations that rarely overlap.

This combination of digital marketing firms that are required to reveal little about what they do, and digital ads that are different for each segment of the population, make political advertising online opaque in way traditional ads were not.

And the approach seems to work. A more sophisticated digital strategy is regularly cited by Cummings and other Leave campaigners as as example of how they outsmarted Remain. If you were planning how to win June’s election, you’d be mad not to pay close attention to how they did it, and do your best to replicate it. And that means as we approach yet another nationwide vote, it will be harder than ever to see what impact money and the political advertising it pays for is having on the result.

China to question Apple about use of app streaming to beat censors China to question Apple about use of app streaming to beat censors The real secret of Chinese internet censorship? Distraction | John Naughton

Chinese authorities will question Apple over live-streaming video software available on the company’s app store, amid an increasingly hostile business environment for foreign firms in the world’s second largest economy.

Police, cyberspace administration and cultural law enforcement team will jointly summon Apple, state news agency Xinhua reported, as part of a wider crackdown on live-streaming video services.

The three Chinese government agencies planned to tell Apple to “tighten up checks” on software offered on its app store. Law enforcement officers had already met with Apple representatives over live-streaming services, Xinhua reported, but did not provide details of the meetings.

The inquiry appears to be focused on third-party apps available for download through Apple’s online marketplace. The company did not respond to requests for comment.

China operates the world’s largest internet censorship regime, blocking a host of foreign websites including Google, Facebook, Twitter and Instagram, but the authorities __have struggled to control an explosion in popularity of live-streaming video apps.

China accounted for almost a quarter of Apple’s worldwide revenue in the company’s most recent financial quarter, and the app store is increasingly important as sales of iPhones and iPad in China slow. Over the past year, Apple has twice been forced to shut or remove services from China at the government’s request.

As part of the inquiry into live-streaming, three Chinese websites – toutiao.com, huoshanzhibo.com and huajiao.com – were already found to __have violated internet regulations, and had broadcast content that violated Chinese law, including providing “pornographic content”, the Xinhua report said. Pornography is banned in China.

The three sites were told to increase oversight of live-broadcasting services, user registration and “the handling of tips-offs”. Two of the websites, huoshanzhibo.com and huajiao.com, were under formal investigation and may have their cases transferred to the police for criminal prosecutions, the Xinhua report said.

Rules issued by China’s cyberspace administration in June 2016 ban apps from “publishing or disseminating prohibited information or content”.

Casting a wide net, the regulations state that apps cannot “engage in activities prohibited by laws and regulations such as endangering national security, disrupting social order and violating the legitimate rights and interests of others”.

A recent survey showed American businesses in China are facing one of the toughest climates in decades, largely due to increasing animosity towards foreign firms and slowing economic growth.

Barriers to investment remain high, the American Chamber of Commerce in China said, despite China’s attempts to project an image of globalisation and openness, and about 81% of the chamber’s members said they felt unwelcome in 2016, an increase from 77% in 2015.

In December, Apple removed the New York Times app from its store in China after a government request. The newspaper’s website has been blocked in China since 2012 after it published a story detailing the wealth of former prime minister Wen Jiabao and his family.

Last year, authorities also forced Apple to shutter its iBooks and iTunes movie platforms in China, where print and online media is tightly controlled.

Teachers on Twitter: why you should join and how to get started Teachers on Twitter: why you should join and how to get started Top 10 don'ts for wannabe teacher bloggers Top tips for using social media to improve teaching and boost CPD

I’ve been using Twitter for six months and it’s already one of the best career decisions I’ve made.

For a while, it seemed that my relationship with teaching was going to be short lived (the first rush of excitement and energy was gone and in need of resuscitation). But thanks to some of the inspiring educators on Twitter, I __have fallen back in love with teaching.

Earlier this year, a colleague (@historychappy) presented a 10-minute continuing professional development session on how to expand your personal learning network. By the end of the session I was convinced by his ideas, and have since found Twitter to be an excellent way to develop professionally.

Over the past few months, I __have learned so much, not only about classroom teaching but also about wider educational debates. Here’s why I think all teachers should join the conversation, and some tips for getting started.

Find and share resources

Whatever resource you are about to make, stop – open Twitter and explore what is already available. Chances are that another teacher will have created something that is perfect for you, and is using strategies you’ve never thought of.

The productivity and generosity of teachers on Twitter is inspiring and I have also become more efficient in creating and sharing resources. Collaborating with online colleagues is an enlightening experience and as teachers we should want all students to learn, not just the ones in front of us.

Be informed

The blogs of some incredible teachers have taught me far more about my profession, and given me more practical ideas, than my MA in education did. There is some incredibly useful research being carried out in education, but I didn’t encounter any of it until joining Twitter and following groups such as The Learning Scientists (@AceThatTest).

And after a few days of reading blogs on everyday practice, my approach to lessons was re-energised. I’ve taken many useful pointers from Rebecca Foster (@TLPMsF) especially, who blogs weekly about practical ideas for the classroom.

Get a fresh perspective

It’s fair to say that teachers are cruelly generalised. We are often portrayed as a miserable bunch, constantly striking and always angry about the latest injustice imposed on our education system. Even to me, the word “teacher” conjures an image of an exhausted, underpaid and overworked drone, counting down the years until retirement.

But this is not the case. Teachers of all ages and nationalities come together on Twitter and they are excited about the profession, their subjects and the students they teach. I’ve found that if you choose to associate yourself with these types of people, you might well become one.

Embrace new ideas

Looking at teachers’ Twitter accounts will show you that we’re a diverse group and that many reject some of the prescriptive ideas instilled by PGCE training about how to be an outstanding teacher. Some of us have come to feel that much of the advice was just preventing us from being bad teachers, rather than encouraging us to be the unique teachers we wanted to be.

Early in my career, I had a suspicion that I liked didactic teaching. My PGCE experience made me afraid of “teacher talk” but Twitter made me realise that I was not alone and that there are schools built on the principles of didactic teaching. Without Twitter, I would never have read the blogs of their wonderful head teachers reassuring me that I wasn’t meant for the dark ages.

There are so many incredible teachers, each with their own approach that they are happy to share. Twitter has opened my eyes to the fact that there isn’t just one teaching style. I am proud to say that I’ve embraced different ideas and believe my teaching has improved as a result.

Change the conversation

With marking, meetings, parents’ evenings, administrative tasks and exam entries, teachers aren’t left with much time to discuss teaching practices with colleagues. But we want to talk about what works. On Twitter, it’s refreshing to get an outside view, away from the politics and day-to-day conversations of your own school.

How to get tweeting

  • First, set up a profile. Most teachers seem to use their real names, but you can make your account private, so that students can’t find you.
  • You’ll be asked to select areas of interest: choose education, schools and anything else that takes your fancy.
  • Add your interests to the “About You” section, so that people with similar interests can follow you, and you can build mutually beneficial professional relationships.
  • Follow everyone to begin with, then narrow it down. Twitter will then recognise the types of people you engage with and refine its recommendations. I’ve learned so much from @MrsSpalding, @FKRitson, @fod3, @mr_englishteach and @shadylady222 about teaching English. For wider educational debates, @DavidDidau and @JamesTheo are always posting interesting thoughts.
  • Take part in discussions, read blogs and see what resources are around. Teachers seem to be on Twitter and chatting on weekday evenings, and most subject areas have a specific chat period. For English, @engchatuk sets up a discussion on Monday evenings that anyone can host.
  • Use and follow hashtags. As an English teacher, #teamenglish is essential, and you can find hashtags for your subject areas and more here .
  • Think before you type and remember your Ps and Qs. Remember that the veil of a screen does not mean people won’t be offended.
  • Be a radiator, not a drain. Don’t just take resources, share them too. The lovely education bubble on Twitter can only exist for as long as we keep sharing ideas and resources.

If you’re already a teacher on Twitter, thank you. If you’re not, I hope I’ve convinced you to join. I promise that Twitter will save you more time than it will ever cost you.

Erin Miller tweets @Miss_E_Miller.

Follow us on Twitter via @GuardianTeach. Join the Guardian Teacher Network for lesson resources, comment and job opportunities, direct to your inbox

Push to impose GST on all imported online goods breaches best-practice rules Push to impose GST on all imported online goods breaches best-practice rules Australia Post hits back at Amazon and eBay and says Coalition's GST model is best Plan for GST on all overseas purchases 'fails to understand online markets'

Treasury officials __have admitted the Turnbull government’s push to impose the goods and services tax on all online goods imported to Australia is in breach of its own best-practice requirements.

They say that when the former treasurer Joe Hockey announced the plan in August 2015 he had not completed a regulatory impact statement.

Australian Taxation Office officials __have also conceded the government’s plan to force overseas websites to collect GST on goods imported to Australia would be difficult to police. They say consumers will have no way of knowing if GST charged on items they bought from overseas will ever return to Australia.

Their evidence will provide ammunition to the internet giants Amazon, eBay, and Alibaba, who do not want the government’s GST bill to proceed.

The stinging evidence was heard at a Senate inquiry in Melbourne on Friday. The treasurer, Scott Morrison, is pushing ahead with plans to impose the 10% GST on all online goods purchased from overseas.

At the moment, imports of goods worth less than $1,000 are GST-free but the government wants to abolish the concession. It comes after years of heavy lobbying from local retail giants such as Gerry Harvey.

Under the plan, the Coalition wants to use a so-called “vendor model” to force companies such as Amazon and eBay to collect the GST on online goods imported to Australia.

But Marisa Purvis-Smith, the head of Treasury’s individuals and indirect tax division, says the plan is in breach of the government’s best-practice requirements. She told senators the government had chosen the “vendor model” without subjecting it to a regulatory impact statement. “Up on the Office of Best Practice Regulation website, Treasury is found to be in breach of the regulation guidelines,” Purvis-Smith said.

It prompted Labor senator Chris Ketter to ask: “So the Senate is going to be asked to vote on a bill which doesn’t comply with the government’s regulatory guidelines. Has that happened before?

Purvis-Smith replied: “I would need to take that on notice, Senator.” She also said if Australia introduced the vendor registration model in July it would be the first country in the world to do so.

Switzerland has legislated a vendor model but it will not come into effect until the beginning of 2018.

Amazon has already attacked the Turnbull government’s plan, saying it is so poorly designed it will create an “inherent disincentive” to comply. It said the government should be asking Australia Post to collect GST on goods imported to Australia but Australia Post says that would render its parcels business “unviable”.

On Friday ATO officials said they had compiled a list of 3,000 overseas companies that would need to register with Australia’s government to collect GST on the government’s behalf.

But they said the US and Chinese governments would be under no obligation to force companies operating within their borders to comply with the Australian government’s wishes.

The deputy ATO commissioner Timothy Dyce said he believed most organisations that had an obligation to comply with the legislation would do so.

Ketter asked: “Can you just tell me what’s led you to that belief?”

Dyce replied: “The model that’s been proposed, they’re predominantly large organisations that have a history globally of complying with obligations that they’re required to comply with.”

What Brexit should have taught us about voter manipulation What Brexit should have taught us about voter manipulation Cambridge Analytica affair raises questions vital to our democracy

The single thunderous lesson from the EU referendum is that new technology trumps arcane democratic safeguards. Artificial intelligence, algorithms and invisible money sources can overwhelm democratic rules.

A report by MPs on the public administration and constitutional affairs committee – Lessons Learned from the EU Referendum – gained considerable attention after highlighting the possibility that foreign governments interfered with the referendum. The voter registration website crashed last June, threatening the disenfranchisement of thousands of people, forcing the government to extend the registration deadline. Crashing a website is a technical instance where cause, effect and hopefully blame can be established. The UK’s National Cyber Security Centre deals with around 200 such cases a day. The committee reported that the crash had indications of a botnet attack.

Botnets are online tools programmed to manipulate public opinion through social media platforms. A significant number of Twitter users are bots that can act to spam and manipulate public opinion on current affairs. The crash may well __have been the result of an attack designed to influence political outcome.

But a much more troubling narrative is emerging. The use of algorithms and artificial intelligence was probably a significant but invisible element in the campaigns. There is no evidence that Cambridge Analytica, the data analytics firm linked to the Leave.EU campaign, used botnets or any other illegal activity – it seeks to use the web to manipulate public opinion through legal means. Legal though such methods are, the sinister nature of this manipulation requires robust regulation.

Broadcast advertising is subject to strict controls in the interests of fair play, as it traditionally had a wide reach and great impact. Recent shifts __have proved unfair advantages are now to be gained from targeted online activity.

An elite group is shaping world politics to suit their private beliefs, and their behaviour has untold and unquantifiable effects. While the plot reads like a comic book, this cyber-manipulation is no fiction and played a role in the EU referendum and Donald Trump’s election.

Exceptional investigative work by Carole Cadwalladr has exposed the wide-reaching implications of this issue. It’s not just the EU referendum. Billionaire Robert Mercer is Trump’s biggest donor. He is also reported to be an owner of Cambridge Analytica. Nigel Farage’s links with Mercer led to Cambridge Analytica’s involvement in the Leave.EU campaign. The company proved to be instrumental and taught the campaign how to build profiles, target people and gain data from Facebook profiles.

When interviewed by Cadwalladr, Leave.EU’s communications director admitted Facebook was the key to the entire campaign. A Facebook “like” was their most potent weapon. “Using artificial intelligence, as we did, tells you all sorts of things about that individual and how to convince them with what sort of advert. And you knew there would also be other people in their network who liked what they liked, so you could spread. And then you follow them. The computer never stops learning and it never stops monitoring.”

So worrying are Cambridge Analytica’s actions that the Information Commissioner’s Office is looking into the firm’s reported use of personal data.

There is contempt for the electoral process. Leave.EU admits that Cambridge Analytica helped the campaign but was not paid. It seems clear that this type of work should have been declared to the Electoral Commission as a services-in-kind donation. It has not been. Arron Banks of Leave.EU has since declared: “I don’t give a monkey’s about the Electoral Commission.”

Lobbyists and billionaires are wilfully manipulating the media and public opinion in defiance of transparency regulations. Cambridge Analytica, while the most high-profile group, is only one element of this sordid tale that sees foreign funds influence our electoral processes.

Cambridge Analytica may not use bots, but other forces clearly do. Research from University College London explains how a large group of bots can misrepresent public opinion. “They could tweet like real users, but coordinated centrally around a specific topic. They could all post positive or negative tweets skewing metrics used by companies and researchers to track opinions on that topic.” Bots can even “orchestrate a campaign to create a fake sense of agreement among Twitter users where they mask the sponsor of the message, making it seem like it originates from the community itself”.

Evidence from Oxford Internet Institute suggest that a third of all Twitter traffic prior to the EU referendum was actually bots and that this type of targeting was used as recently as the Stoke-on-Trent Central byelection.

Together, this evidence makes it clear that democracy is struggling to stand tall in a disturbing era where lobbyists can weaponise fake news for the highest bidder, while bodies such as the Electoral Commission do not have the resources to intervene and sanction. Malign forces can track voters’ personal data and manipulate public opinion as if it were in fact using cyber-deception. All of this they can do under cover of anonymity and free of regulation or oversight.

The EU referendum was a battle of dishonesty. It was won by the side with the means to distribute the most plausible lies.

MiVote aims to shake up democratic process with a click and a tap MiVote aims to shake up democratic process with a click and a tap Apps for democracy – open data and the future of politics Can democracy survive the fourth industrial revolution? Should it? Cormann stares down One Nation's demand to cut $600m from ABC

Disruption of the democratic process is within arm’s reach, according to MiVote, the democracy start-up that plans to use the internet and mobile devices for voters to set the direction of their country.

Its founder, Adam Jacoby, believes that offering a platform to educate voters and help them choose from a range of policy options will help break undemocratic binary options and deadlocks on issues as broad as refugee policy and the energy mix.

MiVote, which already claims several thousand members in Australia and plans to expand into the United States and Canada, also aims to shake up some of the least popular elements of the democratic system. These include refusing donations, setting a two-term limit on its elected representatives, and binding any parliamentarians it gets elected to the will of the people.

Jacoby said he believed MiVote could succeed where others, such as the Flux party, had failed, because it offered a “redesign of the democratic model” rather than being just another technology solution applied to politics.

The MiVote website and application runs regular fortnightly votes on policy questions. Before participants can vote, they must read about the policy problem and are presented with four possible solutions.

Votes __have already determined that 89% of the participants support direct democracy and 69% would prefer politicians’ pay to be increased but want their entitlements to end when they leave office. The start-up is now conducting a vote on the energy mix.

“All the other technology systems offer yes-no, black-white binaries. We’re different – we say, here are four options, we want a tolerance check of which you could live with ... and you can vote for more than one,” Jacoby said.

That reflects policy-making as it should be, he said, citing the example of asylum seekers. “The way the issue is put to us that you either care about protecting the borders or a humanitarian solution and can’t want both things, is a nonsense.

“They aren’t binary – want to protect borders but in a humane way. But our current system doesn’t allow to make those choices.”

MiVote aims to get senators elected on a platform of following the direction set by voters. If elected, they would be prohibited from offering personal views, and then bound to follow the voters’ will.

Jacoby said the votes would determine the “destination”, or long-term priorities, rather than having “granular legislative conversations” about how the party should vote bill by bill.

For example, voters would be asked if they were more concerned about electricity prices, climate change, helping industry and jobs, or meeting international commitments, and parliamentarians would vote on energy policy according to their judgement of how to enact that direction.

“We’re not saying that MiVote is going make decisions on an app and that will replace representative government,” Jacoby said.

“It’s an incremental shift ... we recognise the need for representative government, but the role of the representative needs to be different.

“They need to be more responsive to the will of the people and they will be held more accountable and deliver a less ideological approach.”

Jacoby accuses minor parties, including the Nick Xenophon Team and Pauline Hanson’s One Nation, of being “brokers for their world view” that they enact through horse-trading and modification of government legislation.

“Whether you agree with those parties or not, it’s undemocratic,” he said, citing One Nation’s threat not to support government savings bills unless it cuts funding to the ABC.

“Nobody ever asked the people whether they want those things to be tied, or whether they want ABC to be cut.

“You won’t see bartering at the table [with the MiVote platform] – you either come to us with a proposal that we can support based on votes of members or we will never support it.”

Blockchain technology to secure votes

Jacoby believed the platform could defeat concerns raised by cybersecurity experts about electronic voting by using a two-step authentication and use of blockchain technology.

Vanessa Teague, a computing academic with expertise in electronic voting, raised three security issues with the MiVote platform: eligibility, or how it would determine its users were who they said they were and could vote; verifying that their votes were recorded and tallied correctly without interference; and ensuring their privacy.

We recognise the need for representative government, but the role of the representative needs to be different.

Adam Jacoby

Teague said the system required “an opportunity to challenge the vote that you’ve made ... [including] a secondary computer to double check the encryption, that it’s the one you asked for”.

Jacoby responded by saying that Australians aged 16 and over would be eligible, and the fact that telecommunications companies had to check 100 points of identification would ensure that users were who they say they were.

Two-step authentication, sending an SMS code to the phone for every vote, would secure the vote process. The answers would be recorded in the Ethereum blockchain, which would form a decentralised voting ledger across thousands of computers, and the information about the voter would be kept separate from where their votes were stored.

“They all __have an auditable record of the vote, so that if you hacked one and tried to change the vote, the others would reject that outcome,” Jacoby said.

“We can always see your vote and we can audit it in the backend if challenged.”

Teague said the threat model of the system was “a different order of magnitude” to the risk of hacking of electronic voting in an election.

“The resources that someone might devote to hacking it are probably less – it doesn’t mean it wouldn’t happen, but the implications are probably less than if we used the internet to elect our representatives.”

Teague also supported the “admirable” aim of the project, saying “the existing methods of choosing how MPs vote on conscience votes are totally undemocratic, so I can totally understand why people might think involving constituents more is a good thing”.

The director of threat intelligence for cybersecurity firm Mandiant at FireEye, Tim Wellsmore, said the use of blockchain technology for electronic voting was “a step forward” but two-step authentication was not foolproof.

“MiVote’s use of blockchain is quite a novel approach, it would benefit some of the problems with electronic voting like the integrity of data in a central database.

“And it’s also public, which means if there is a change made to it, it can be seen.”

But Wellsmore said mobile apps and internet-connected devices were never invulnerable, because malicious software could bypass even two-factor authentication on mobiles.

“Criminals are accessing people’s bank accounts, and infecting their mobiles so they can acknowledge receipt of an SMS and take a code off people’s phones, so two-factor authentication is not foolproof.”

Jacoby said that while MiVote and Ethereum had not been successfully hacked, “like everything” they could not guarantee it was the perfect model – only that it would evolve if difficulties arose.

EU launches public consultation into fears about future of internet EU launches public consultation into fears about future of internet

The EU is launching an unprecedented public consultation to find out what Europeans fear most about the future of the internet.

A succession of surveys over the coming weeks will ask people for their views on everything from privacy and security to artificial intelligence, net neutrality, big data and the impact of the digital world on jobs, health, government and democracy.

A dozen leading European publications, including the Guardian, are to publicise the surveys over the coming three weeks. Results will be compiled in early June. Readers can complete the first questionnaire here.

“Science should be open and freed from its traditional ivory tower; to be discussed, submitted to critique and fed with new perspectives,” said Jean-Claude Juncker, the president of the European commission, adding that the consultation would “inspire fresh ideas about how to solve some of our society’s most pressing problems”.

The project is being led by REIsearch, a non-profit initiative co-funded by the European commission. The aim is to give policymakers a better sense of public priorities in their decision-making. The European commission is often criticised for being too detached from popular sentiment and preoccupation.

The newspapers and publications involved are Der Standard, El País, Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, La Libre Belgique, Gazeta Wyborcza, Luxemburger Wort, Público, Il Sole 24 Ore, The Lancet, Cell and the Guardian.

Brussels policymakers __have long sought to tap into the internet to boost Europe’s economic growth and the EU’s popularity. In his state of the union speech in September 2016, Juncker called for every town and village to __have free wifi by 2020, a demanding target that initially rattled the telecoms industry. Closer inspection showed the proposed free wifi would not quite reach every remote hamlet and far-flung outpost of the EU: the commission expects 8,000 towns and villages to benefit from its €120m (£101m) free wifi fund, known as WiFi4EU.

The EU executive is also leaning on the telecoms industry to do more to upgrade internet speeds. It wants schools, most businesses, railway stations and airports to benefit from broadband speeds of one gigabit per second by 2025. (The best-connected schools have internet speeds of around 30 megabits per second, but many are far behind).

To spur on the rollout of fast broadband, telecoms companies could see a relaxation in EU rules that force them to open up their network to competitors. Firms, such as Deutsche Telekom and Telecom Italia, have long argued it is hard to get a return on investing in fibre-optic cables, because they must open their networks to competitors.

It is the commission’s role as a competition watchdog that has brought it into conflict with some of the most powerful technology companies. Smartphone maker Apple has been ordered to repay €13bn in unpaid taxes, after the competition commissioner found it had benefited from a sweetheart deal from the Irish government, which amounted to illegal state aid. The commission is currently investigating Google for abusing its dominant position. Meanwhile, Amazon has tried to ward off a potential fine, by offering to change contracts with publishers, following an EU anti-trust investigation.

The EU’s wide-ranging regulatory powers also extend to guaranteeing “net neutrality”, ensuring that all web traffic is treated equally, as well as setting online privacy standards. MEPs want the EU to start regulating artificial intelligence and have even called for “rights for robots”, in the form of electronic personhood for the most advanced AI. But the commission is not obliged to follow this advice.

“The internet’s impact on our world is already enormous and will accelerate even more in the coming years with the rise of artificial intelligence, the bridging of the physical and digital worlds and the pervasive use of data,” said Jesús Villasante, a commission official.

“We believe the digital world should respect the same values and rights we enjoy in the physical one. We also believe Europe has the potential to be a key player in internet matters even if many important decisions are taken elsewhere.”

Forget driverless tech – white-van man will keep on trucking Forget driverless tech – white-van man will keep on trucking Self-driving cars will only work when we accept autonomy is a myth

On holiday in Venice recently, I found myself thinking a lot about driverless trucks. This may seem strange, because there are no trucks in Venice. Instead, everything is delivered by boat. At 6am every morning, for example, a large, broad-bottomed boat turned up and moored outside the small supermarket across the bridge from our hotel. The driver (or should I say captain?) then used the onboard crane to lift out heavy pallets of bottled water, boxes of provisions etc on to the quayside. Delivering the necessary supplies in this way took at least 30 minutes, after which he gunned the engine of the boat and headed off to make his next delivery.

Later that particular day, walking along the Grand Canal, we came across another large boat, this time emblazoned with the logo of DHL, the international couriers. The boat was piled high with cardboard boxes and two guys with clipboards were trying to sort out what needed to be delivered where. It was clearly a slow and painstaking process.

In both cases, the boats are the Venetian equivalent of the white vans that, in the UK, deliver stuff from Amazon et al. So, on my return, I whiled away an hour or two watching white-van drivers at work. It turns out that the driving is the easy bit: the real tasks are things like finding a place to park on a busy street, dodging traffic wardens, finding a house number or the right apartment in a block of flats, deciding what to do when there’s no one at home, getting a signature from a customer, and so on.

The trouble starts when the vehicle has to leave the motorway in order to reach its final destination

All of which helps to put the hype about driverless trucks into perspective. The narrative about autonomous vehicles that is being fostered by the tech industry and its media acolytes is that the technology is unstoppable and that it’s coming real soon now to a road near you. This is a subgenre of a bigger narrative about the inevitability of AI, robotics and automation generally. It’s basically technological determinism on steroids. And what it boils down to is this: if something can be done, then it will be done. And there’s nothing we can do to stop it, so anyone who is sceptical about the narrative is – wait for it – a luddite!

That this Manichaean, yah-boo discourse is idiotic, misleading and unproductive goes without saying. Technology has always been one of the forces that drive society, and technologies that historically went mainstream __have usually done so because they offered great benefits to society. Think of public sanitation, vaccination, antibiotics, electricity, the internet – and, yes, maybe autonomous vehicles. Self-driving cars could make urban life safer, greener and more enjoyable, for example. And given that our economies __have become totally dependent on logistics systems based on trucks, anything that makes trucks safer and more economical sounds like a good idea. Such vehicles could run 24/7 (no need for driver rest breaks), and at lower speeds (thereby saving fuel). And they would probably be significantly safer (because many accidents are a product of human error). And so on.

But while the potential benefits of new technology are great, that doesn’t mean it will automatically be adopted. In some cases, the social costs might greatly outweigh the benefits. But usually the biggest brakes on adoption come from economic and practical considerations. Consumers may not be the rational creatures of economists’ dreams, but most corporations are. They will invest in technology only if it makes economic sense to do so. One of the reasons the automation of jobs is happening so slowly at the moment is that, in important market segments, low wages make human employees cheap. Why invest in expensive, dextrous robots if you can have people on zero-hours contracts and pay them the minimum wage?

But the biggest impediments to automation are the practical difficulties that tech evangelists tend to ignore. Some of them have already sussed that self-driving cars are a distant prospect because their regulatory and infrastructural requirements are so complex. That’s why much of the excitement in the industry is now focused on trucks. It’s easy to see how autonomous “truck trains” could work on motorways, and indeed there have already been trials of such convoys.

The trouble starts when the vehicle has to leave the motorway in order to reach its final destination. Suddenly the truck faces the same obstacles as the self-driving car. So maybe it will be necessary to have human pilots to take it that last mile safely, just as ships have pilots to guide them into harbour. That’s also why we are unlikely to see autonomous white vans any time soon: their drivers do much more than simply drive – just like those DHL guys in Venice. So perhaps tech determinists need to revise their mantra: if something can be done, then it may be done – provided the economics and the practicalities are right.

Robert Taylor, internet and computer pioneer, dies aged 85 Robert Taylor, internet and computer pioneer, dies aged 85 How the internet was invented

Robert Taylor, who was instrumental in creating the internet and the modern personal computer, has died. He was 85.

Taylor, who had Parkinson’s disease, died on Thursday at his home in the San Francisco peninsula community of Woodside, his son, Kurt Taylor, told the Los Angeles Times and the New York Times.

“Any way you look at it, from kick-starting the internet to launching the personal computer revolution, Bob Taylor was a key architect of our modern world,” Leslie Berlin, a historian at the Stanford University Silicon Valley Archives project, told the New York Times.

In 1961, Taylor was a project manager for Nasa when he directed funding to Douglas Engelbart at the Stanford Research Institute, who helped develop the modern computer mouse.

Taylor was working for the Pentagon’s Advanced Research Projects Agency (Arpa) in 1966 when he shepherded the creation of a single computer network to link Arpa-sponsored researchers at companies and institutions around the country.

Taylor was frustrated that he had to use three separate terminals to communicate with the researchers through their computer systems.

Arpanet, as it was known, evolved into the internet. As Taylor predicted, the limited communications tool morphed into a system that supplies people with fingertip access to everything from encyclopedias to investment advice.

A few years later, Taylor went on to work at Xerox’s famous Palo Alto Research Center, or Parc, where he was oversaw a team that helped create the Alto, a pioneering personal computer.

The Alto supplied each researcher with an individual workstation instead of sharing time on a room-sized mainframe. It was designed to use a graphical user interface, which enabled the user to command the device through icons, windows and menus instead of typing text commands in computer language.

The technology inspired Microsoft’s Windows software and the Apple computers.

Taylor’s engineering team also helped develop the ethernet and a word processing program that became Microsoft Word.

In 1999, Taylor was awarded the National Medal of Technology and Innovation. In 2004, he and other Parc researchers were awarded the Draper prize from the National Academy of Engineering for development of “the first practical networked personal computers”.

In the 1990s, Taylor ran the Systems Research Center in Palo Alto for Digital Equipment Corporation. The lab helped create AltaVista, one of the first internet search engines. Taylor retired in 1996.

In addition to Kurt, he is survived by his sons Erik and Derek and three grandchildren.

A newsreader’s redemption – for once social media got it right A newsreader’s redemption – for once social media got it right

It is a story for our age: an Australian newsreader caught off guard by the end of a prerecorded report. When the camera returns to her she is busy contemplating her pen with gormless intensity. She suddenly realises she is on air, and takes on the expression of a cartoon character who’s just seen a ghost: her eyes bug, her mouth forms a perfect O, and her sharp intake of breath is audible. Then she recovers, reads the next link, and smiles.

It’s a story for our age because, as you can see from that summary, it’s not really a story at all. Except the clip went viral. The result is a fairly highbrow example of the “newsreader fail” subgenre, in that no one vomits, but it’s funny. There were reports that the newsreader, Natasha Exelby, had been “benched” by news channel ABC24 for her gaffe. A Twitter backlash followed: Russell Crowe called it an “over reaction [sic] to an over reaction [sic]”.

ABC’s first official statement was not exactly a heartfelt show of support: “Natasha Exelby is a casual contributor, not a staff member.” By then other newsreaders had confessed to their own embarrassing moments – corpsing on air, eating on air, dancing in their seats when the camera was meant to be pointed elsewhere. The overwhelming response was one of solidarity – we’ve all made mistakes we thought might cost us our jobs. ABC finally denied it ever meant to cut Exelby loose, a rival outfit gave her a slot, and now she’s a national hero. Not bad, when you consider the original clip was from last weekend.

Our sense of basic etiquette has never kept pace with the viral reach of social media, but we are catching up. We’re slowly learning when to replace scorn with sympathy, and how to judge mistakes that __have been amplified out of all proportion. But corporations can still be relied upon for a tin-eared response: abandoning employees over innocent bloopers, standing by them when a passenger is dragged bleeding from a plane. They may never get it.

I may never completely get it. In fact, I’ve probably made too much of the whole business.

Surplus to requirement

For me one of the greatest advances of our age is the wide and immediate availability of spare parts. Forget duct tape and epoxy resin – if you __have a model number, you can have a new refrigerator shelf bracket in 12 hours.

I’ve patronised many of these services, to the extent that I now receive about two emails a day – usually purporting to be from an actual person – offering me hot deals on toothbrush chargers and oven knobs. I’m as keen on a bargain as the next person, but my need for spare parts is driven only by breakage or loss, never by desire. I have no use for a £25 voucher that expires in three days. I don’t care if your sale on dishwasher rack replacement wheels ends at midnight. On this front at least, I cannot be tempted.

My Natasha Exelby moment

I suppose that expressing solidarity with Exelby ought to require some admission of professional incompetence, even if I still don’t see the funny side myself. I’ve never read the news on TV but about 20 years ago I interviewed a noted broadcaster over the phone for about 30 minutes, only to discover after I’d hung up that the tape on which I recorded our discussion was completely blank.

It took me another 30 minutes to work up the nerve to ring her back, confess my mistake and persuade her to do the interview all over again. In hindsight I can see a face-saving third way – I should have rung with a few supplementary questions, and then tried to drag the discussion back over old ground – but at the time owning up to idiocy was my only strategy.

I still go red thinking about it.

John Redwood mocked for telling people to buy non-existent British cars John Redwood mocked for telling people to buy non-existent British cars A Mini part's incredible journey shows how Brexit will hit the UK car industry

The Conservative MP John Redwood has provoked derision on social media with a call to buy cars manufactured in Britain. He tweeted:

Twitter users promptly responded that very few of the cars assembled in Britain were made by British companies. The majority are destined for export, made by companies that are not British-owned and rely on components manufactured overseas.

Others were quick to suggest that British-made vehicles of the past did not __have the best of reputations.

According to the AA, which produces a guide to buying British cars, there are only three fully British-owned car manufacturers in the UK: Morgan, Caterham and McLaren.

All three produce high-end luxury cars. Morgan markets the EV3, a £52,000 bespoke hand-crafted electric car.

The AA also lists models that are assembled in Britain, but which do not __have British owners. These include Mini, Honda, Toyota, Nissan, Lotus, Aston Martin, Bentley, Rolls Royce, Jaguar, Land Rover and Vauxhall.

Social media users also commented that at least one manufacturer in the UK appears to have needed a post-Brexit vote “sweetener” deal to be convinced to continue to invest in the country.

The car manufacturing process is highly intertwined with the customs union that the UK will leave as part of a hard Brexit. The crankshaft of a BMW Mini, for example, crosses the channel three times, travels 2,000 miles and visits England, France and Germany during its manufacture.

Redwood, the MP for Wokingham, has long been an advocate for leaving the EU. He has argued that Brexit will enable an end to austerity politics in the UK and has been campaigning for the government to adopt a buy-British policy on buses and trains.

In a blog post on Friday about buying British goods, Redwood argued that “if by any chance the rest of the EU does turn down our offer of tariff free trade in an unlikely fit of self harm, we can find plenty of cheaper and better substitutes” such as English cheese and English wine.

Google runs workshops to help UK teenagers tackle hate speech Google runs workshops to help UK teenagers tackle hate speech Google 'may build an adblocker into Chrome' Music industry goes to war with YouTube

Google has responded to a barrage of criticism that it must do more to tackle online hate by launching a series of workshops for teenagers on how to tackle hate speech and fake news.

The workshops, called Internet Citizens, will be launched by YouTube, the Google-owned video streaming service, for people aged 13 to 18 in cities across the UK as part of its Creators for Change programme. They are intended to raise awareness around issues such as tolerance, empathy and abuse online.

The government pulled advertising from Google and YouTube last month after adverts funded by the taxpayer were placed alongside extremist content on the video site. An influential group of MPs from the home affairs select committee wrote to the company, accusing it of “profiting from hatred” just days after accusing Google, Twitter and Facebook of “commercial prostitution” because of a failure to tackle hate speech on their platforms.

The Labour MP Yvette Cooper, chair of the committee, said that despite reassurances during a committee hearing that the companies did not allow hate speech or terrorist content to be monetised, media reports had revealed that was not the case.

YouTube said the Internet Citizens programme would be used to teach skills on how to participate safely and responsibly online, and would include input from the youth mentor Efe Ezekiel.

The site’s head of public policy, Naomi Gummer, said: “Nearly all of us will __have come across comments or content online that shocked or even offended us, sometimes leaving us feeling isolated or powerless to change the conversation.

“And for young people in particular, this sense of vulnerability can be heightened if it’s difficult to judge whether a piece of content is real, especially when something is shared on social media by a trusted friend. That’s why we’re launching Internet Citizens.”

The curriculum for the programme has been designed by experts from the Institute for Strategic Dialogue, the charity UK Youth and the youth marketing firm Livity, and is part of wider plans to tackle abuse online.

“This is just one part of our commitment to a better web,” Gummer said. “Alongside this, we are exploring more innovative ways to use technology; to partner with experts to help us tackle hate speech online and we are taking a hard look at our policies around offensive content. We’ll share more updates on these areas in the coming weeks.”

UK Youth’s chief executive, Anna Smee, said: “Young people in the UK spend more time online than ever before. In this complex world, there is an urgent need to help young people embrace the positive aspects of connectivity, but we must also support them to manage the negative effects.

“Through Internet Citizens, UK Youth is empowering young people to express themselves, __have a voice, listen to others and ultimately gain a sense of belonging by discovering the skills needed to act safely and responsibly online, and make the internet a positive place.”

Amazon Fire TV Stick review: cheap, great TV streaming device with new interface and Alexa Amazon Fire TV Stick review: cheap, great TV streaming device with new interface and Alexa

Amazon’s second generation Fire TV stick – which lets you stream video and apps on your TV – continues the same winning formula but adds new voice search, Alexa assistant and a snappier, more polished experience making it one of the best instant smart TV devices available.

It looks like a USB flash drive, just with an HDMI connector on one end and a microUSB socket in the side. Set up is incredibly easy. Plug it directly into the back of your TV or receiver, or use the included HDMI extension cable if it doesn’t quite fit next to other devices, connect the included microUSB cable to the power adapter and plug it into the stick.

If you bought the Fire TV Stick directly from Amazon then once you’ve put in your wifi password, your account details will already be set up and ready. A few clicks of the Bluetooth remote and a short and useful introductory video that runs through the basics of voice control and you’re ready to go.

You need an Amazon account to use the Fire TV Stick, but you don’t need a Prime subscription. Instead you can buy content or use one of the many TV, movie or music streaming apps available from the Amazon app store, including Netflix, all the UK terrestrial broadcaster catchup services and Spotify.

While you’ll probably already be logged into your Amazon account, you will still __have to enter usernames and passwords for third-party apps such as Netflix. The Amazon Fire TV remote app for Android and iOS makes the process much easier by giving you a full smartphone or tablet keyboard for typing it all in, which is much less tedious than having to scroll an on-screen keyboard using the remote.

Using it

The new Fire TV Stick works just like any other Amazon Fire TV product and most other streaming devices. The remote has a small directional ring for navigating the menu, a back button, home button and an options button, as well as pause-play, fast-forward and rewind buttons.

You don’t __have to point the remote in any particular direction, as it’s Bluetooth not infrared, and takes two AAA batteries which are included. It’s simple, responsive and the new and improved user interface is both attractive and easy to use, with nice big pictures of media, apps and menu options.

The most transformative new thing is that the new remote comes with a microphone built in giving you a one-button push-to-talk functionality. Hold the mic button at the top of the remote to activate Alexa and ask for what you want. It’s the same experience you get from an Echo or Echo Dot device, with full Alexa functionality, but you also get what Amazon calls “cards” that pop up on your TV along with the voice answer.

The cards are not interactive, but give at-a-glance visual versions of the voice output, so when Alexa is telling you it isn’t going to rain that day you’re shown some temperatures and weather icons.

Simple search works very well. If you want to watch the Good Wife, simply hold the button, say “Good Wife” and Alexa will take you to a page showing the Good Wife and a one-button push to watch it. Where there are multiple ways to view it, Alexa will always show you the one included in a subscription you might have before other ways to buy it.

The Good Wife is available on Netflix, but also available for purchase from Amazon. If you have a Netflix subscription logged in, hitting play will take you straight to the next unwatched episode in Netflix. It’s fast, easy to use and transformative if you know what you want to watch.

You can also search using an actor’s name, genre and many other different keywords, but I still find browsing through shows still easier if looking for inspiration, as Amazon or Netflix suggestions are normally better than I would have come up with on my own. The new Fire TV interface also allows Netflix, and soon other third-party apps, to suggest content you might be interested in directly within the home screen under their own carrousels, which is useful.

Voice control extends to playback options too, skipping minutes of video, pausing, playing and other functions within Amazon Video.

Smart home control

Full Alexa functionality also extends to smarthome control. Anything you might connect via the Alexa app on your smartphone you can command with the new Fire TV Stick. Hit the mic button, say “turn on the living room lights” and see any Philips Hue or other connected bulbs light up.

Amazon has struck a wide range of partnerships with various smarthome device manufacturers, including Samsung SmartThings, Philips Hue, Nest, Hive and many others, making it one of the most versatile smarthome voice assistants.

  • Alexa, lights! How I turned my home into a sci-fi dream

Observations

  • Jumping straight to a show in Netflix from Alexa uses the last logged in user in Netflix, which means you might end up playing through another family member’s viewer account
  • Voice control is neat, but pressing a button is still quicker
  • There are plenty of games and third-party apps to choose from, with Apple’s iTunes the biggest one missing
  • You can also cast video to the Fire TV Stick from a smartphone or tablet
  • Parental control options are available to limit purchases and content with pin override
  • The Fire TV Stick maxes out at 1080p, which means no UHD 4K support
  • It’s not quite as fast as the Fire TV box, but it is half the price (it is, however, quite a lot faster than the last version of the Fire TV stick)

Price

The new Fire TV Stick with Alexa Voice Remote costs £39.99 making it one of the best value smart TV streaming devices available, and £5 cheaper than the previous version with a voice-enabled remote.

Verdict

The old Fire TV Stick was cheap and effective, but lacked polish. The new Fire TV Stick takes that winning formula and adds a level of polish and competence that’s almost unbeatable for £40.

Setting it up is easy. You have to have an Amazon account and are tied into the firm’s services, but third-party app support is excellent, with all the major UK TV streaming and catchup services bar Apple’s and Sky’s service.

The Alexa support is transformative, making the Stick much more than a basic TV streamer, but also doesn’t get in the way. You can still perform every streaming function without having to utter words, and while Alexa is very capable, the Fire TV Stick doesn’t try to hard to be more than it is – a very good smart TV device in a cheap and effective package.

Pros: simple to use, easy set up, compact, good remote, slick interface, wide UK catchup service support, Alexa integration

Cons: not quite as fast as the more expensive Fire TV box, no support for iTunes or Sky content, requires Amazon account, wifi only

Other reviews

  • Amazon Fire TV review: simple, fast, 4K and the best TV streaming
  • Amazon Echo review: the best combined speaker and voice assistant in the UK
  • Amazon Echo Dot review: as good as the Echo for one-third of the price

Move Fast and Break Things review – Google, Facebook and Amazon exposed Move Fast and Break Things review – Google, Facebook and Amazon exposed No, wealth isn’t created at the top. It is merely devoured there | Rutger Bregman

The internet, defined as the network switched on in January 1983, is now 34 years old. When it began, it was a gloriously decentralised, creative, non-commercial system that evoked in many of its early users utopian hopes about liberation, empowerment, creativity and sticking it to The Man. In those heady days, only a few sceptics wondered how long it would take for capitalism to get a grip on it. Now we know: it took only 21 years.

Opinions vary about the timing, of course. For my money, the critical year was 2004, the year Google had its IPO, Facebook was launched and the business model that became known as “surveillance capitalism” really got a grip on the network. This is the model that provides supposedly free services to users in return for “consent” to mine and exploit their personal data and digital trails in order to target adverts at them.

Jonathan Taplin is an American academic who has also been a successful music and film producer. He has worked with Bob Dylan and the Band and produced Martin Scorsese’s first major film (Mean Streets) plus 12 other feature films (including The Last Waltz, Until the End of the World, Under Fire and To Die For). His films __have been nominated for Academy and Golden Globe awards and chosen for the Cannes film festival.

To this impressive list he has added a bracing, unromantic account of how the internet was captured. It’s the story of how a number of libertarian entrepreneurs began, in the 1990s, to hijack the original distributed vision of the network and in the process created the three giant monopolies – Google, Facebook and Amazon – that now determine the future of all our media industries and may, in the end, also determine how democracy ends.

The title comes from an exhortation of Facebook’s founder, Mark Zuckerberg, to his employees. For him, it was an expression of the hacker ethic common in Silicon Valley, where Joseph Schumpeter’s idea of “creative destruction” is the prevailing religion. But in Taplin’s account, Zuck is really just the hapless schmuck who was led astray by more sinister – and forceful – creatures, such as the entrepreneur Sean Parker and PayPal founder, Peter Thiel, the guy who has become Donald Trump’s tech Savonarola.

Much has been made in previous histories of Silicon Valley’s counter-cultural origins. Taplin finds other, less agreeable roots, notably in the writings of Ayn Rand, a flake of Cadbury proportions who had an astonishing impact on many otherwise intelligent individuals. These include Alan Greenspan, the Federal Reserve chairman who presided over events leading to the banking collapse of 2008, and Thiel, who made an early fortune out of PayPal and was the first investor in Facebook. Rand believed that “achievement of your happiness is the only moral purpose of your life”. She had no time for altruism, government or anything else that might interfere with capitalism red in tooth and claw.

Neither does Thiel. For him, “competition is for losers”. He believes in investing only in companies that __have the potential to become monopolies and he thinks monopolies are good for society. “Americans mythologise competition and credit it with saving us from socialist bread lines,” he once wrote. “Actually, capitalism and competition are opposites. Capitalism is premised on the accumulation of capital, but under perfect competition, all profits get competed away.”

The three great monopolies of the digital world have followed the Thiel playbook and Taplin does a good job of explaining how each of them works and how, strangely, their vast profits are never “competed away”. He also punctures the public image so assiduously fostered by Google and Facebook – that they are basically cool tech companies run by good chaps (and they are still mainly chaps, btw) who are hellbent on making the world a better place – whereas, in fact, they are increasingly hard to distinguish from the older brutes of the capitalist jungle.

They throw their weight around in a distinctly old-fashioned way; for example, Google’s expenditure on political lobbying and the “revolving door”, via which its executives and government officials change places, would make Diageo, BP, Unilever or Anglo American green with envy. The Russian hack of former White House adviser John Podesta’s emails revealed that Google’s chairman, Eric Schmidt, was a permanent resident in Hillary Clinton’s inbox. And so on. In that context, the one thing to be said about Amazon is that what you see is what you get: Jeff Bezos, its founder, never pretended to be a nice guy. Amazon plays hardball in public, whereas the others like to do it behind the scenes.

Taplin’s book ranges widely over the digital landscape and ventures where most commentators rarely go. He looks, for example, at the economic impact of the digital giants and argues convincingly that they are, basically, just engines for increasing inequality. Even as the tech sector booms, we have stagnant living standards, rising inequality and a growing “precariat” in the gig economy. The revenues of Google and Facebook are colossal, and yet they employ very few people in comparison to normal companies: tech firms represent 21% of the 500 largest American firms, but employ only 3% of the workforce.

Similarly, these companies have huge mountains of cash, but invest only a fraction of these reserves in ventures that might create new industries (and jobs). Instead, their executives sit and watch their stockholdings grow exponentially, with the result that only three of the 10 richest men in the Forbes 400 list (Warren Buffett and the two Koch brothers) have not made their money from digital technology.

Move Fast and Break Things is a timely and useful book because it provides an antidote to the self-serving narrative energetically cultivated by the digital monopolies. They have had an easy ride for too long and democracies will, sooner or later, have to rein them in. The first step down that road is to stop viewing them through rose-tinted spectacles and see them for what they really are: enormously powerful corporations that move fast and break things, while minimising their tax bills and shirking the responsibilities that come with their media power.

• Move Fast and Break Things by Jonathan Taplin is published by Pan Macmillan (£18.99). To order a copy for £14.24 go to bookshop.theguardian.com or call 0330 333 6846. Free UK p&p over £10, online orders only. Phone orders min p&p of £1.99

Apr 6, 2017

By dismantling domestic privacy laws, the US will lose control of the global internet By dismantling domestic privacy laws, the US will lose control of the global internet

The numerous paradoxes that will haunt Donald Trump in the coming months were on full display during the recent Senate vote to undo privacy legislation that was passed in the last few years of the Obama administration.

As part of a broader effort to treat internet service providers and telecoms operators as utility companies, Obama imposed restrictions on what these companies could do with all the user data from browsers and apps. Emboldened by Trump, the Republicans __have just allowed these businesses to collect, sell and manipulate such data without user permission.

From the short-sighted domestic perspective, it seems like a boon to the likes of Verizon and AT&T, especially as they increasingly find themselves confronting their data-rich counterparts in Silicon Valley.

Telecoms companies __have been complaining (not entirely without reason) that the Obama administration favoured the interests of Google and Facebook which, invoking the lofty rhetoric of “keeping the internet free” only to defend their own business agenda, have traditionally faced somewhat lighter regulation.

The Democrats, always happy to attack Trump, have jumped on the issue, warning that the Senate vote would foster ubiquitous and extensive surveillance by the telecoms industry – and Silicon Valley, of course, would never commit such sins.

Under the new rules, complained Bill Nelson, a senator from Florida, “your broadband provider may know more about your health – and your reaction to illness – than you are willing to share with your doctor”. Never mind that Google and Facebook already know all this – and much more – and generate little outrage from the Democrats.

The Democrats, of course, only have themselves to blame for such ineptitude. From the early 1980s onwards, centre-left movements on both sides of the Atlantic no longer discussed technology policy in terms of justice, fairness or inequality. Instead, they preferred to emulate their neoliberal opponents and frame choices – about technology policy, but also about many other domains – in terms of just one goal that rules supreme above all other: innovation.

The problem with building a political programme on such flimsy economistic foundations is that it immediately opens the door to competing narratives of just what kind of policy produces more innovation.

Within this debate, the entire history of the internet – a fluid and borderless object that can include everything from mainframe computers to software that powers servers – becomes an extremely contentious theme that, depending on how one slices and dices this very “internet”, can bolster demands for both greater regulation and greater deregulation of digital technologies.

Whatever Trump’s proclaimed departures from the deadening orthodoxy of the Republican party, he shares its bizarre view – endorsed and promoted by Fox News and a new breed of savvy media enterprises, such as Breitbart – that the Democrats are just a bunch of closeted socialists who invoke the highfalutin rhetoric of “human rights” or “humanitarianism” to disguise their real radical agenda.

This piercing insight doesn’t prevent Trump from also attacking Hillary Clinton and her lieutenants as being in the pay of Wall Street and Goldman Sachs: apparently, this is where ardent socialists plan the revolution these days.

However, even a cursory analysis of both Bill Clinton and Obama’s global cheerleading for American businesses during the past two decades would reveal them to possess a set of remarkably robust capitalist instincts. From treaties such as the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership or the Trade in Services Agreement, to the close collaboration between the US Chamber of Congress and the Department of Commerce in pushing the country’s latest technological exports (such as “smart city” technologies sold by Microsoft, Cisco, or IBM), the Democrats have long embraced “America’s capital first” as their motto. In this, they were not so different from the Republicans of the pre-Trump era.

And yet, what Trump and the likes of John Bolton – who represent the unashamedly unilateralist, unhinged wing of the Republican party – take to be the Democrats’ poisonous mix of socialism and humanitarianism is often just a banal mix of capitalism and pseudo-humanitarianism.

It is precisely through constant rhetorical appeals to the universalism of the “global village” that Washington has traditionally justified its economic expansionism – a tactic at work since the days of Woodrow Wilson and hardly an invention of Clinton or Obama. Whatever its theoretical merits, multilateralism as practised by America has always meant “multi-markets” first – and all the rhetorical flourishes second.

Sometimes this rhetoric worked, sometimes it didn’t. But it still required some legitimising in the global arena. So every now and then, Washington had to play nice, rein in its own plutocrats, and make sure that their pillaging of the domestic population didn’t completely undermine the image of prosperity and freedom that underlined America’s dominance abroad.

Obama didn’t much deviate from that script. For example, when the Snowden revelations took place, his administration didn’t simply say, “We’re an empire, we run everyone’s communications, so get on with it”, as, say, the preceding Bush administration might have done. Rather, Obama’s did its utmost to deny that any excessive and authorised surveillance was happening.

There was some logic to it. Who would trust America’s tech companies otherwise? Why would government institutions in Germany, Russia or China agree to store their sensitive documents on servers there?

Obama’s reassuring answer: US intentions were good and it’s to be trusted. And didn’t Obama do his best to defend net neutrality anyway? Any effort to pierce this rhetorical bubble – by pointing out, for example, that restrictions on the free flow of data did not imply restrictions on the freedom of expression but, rather, should be seen as (protectionist) trade instruments, or that there’s a good case to be made for not surrendering a country’s technological sovereignty if one doesn’t want to end up living under Silicon Valley’s neo-colonial regime – was immediately dismissed as reactionary and authoritarian, usually by the same army of Washington thinktanks with close ties to Google, Facebook and Microsoft.

Goaded by the domestic telecoms industry, with little exposure to global markets, Trump may have done more to rekindle the debate about technological sovereignty than all the critics of America’s tech expansionism combined.

While in the short-term, one can imagine how deregulating America’s telecoms will yield short-term gains, it’s hard to imagine how the practices it will permit – including hijacking of our search queries and internet traffic to show more ads and, potentially, infect our devices with malware – could be reconciled with the vision of a heavily Americanised global internet that is voluntarily agreed to by all the parties involved.

It is this unwarranted trust in the Americanised internet that has underpinned the immense growth of one truly healthy sector of the US economy – technology.

Well, goodbye to all that: the era of the Americanised internet is over. Obama could always speak about the need to promote “internet freedom” in authoritarian states, even as he oversaw the most sophisticated surveillance programme in history. The tech sector kept expanding, entering even more foreign markets.

Trump, on the other hand, has no lofty rhetoric to fall back on and the deregulation agenda pursued by the Republicans will alienate whatever international allies he might have kept otherwise. Make America great again by eliminating America’s hegemony over the global internet: try that for a rousing slogan.

OBAMA UNDONE

A new take on doctor-patient confidentiality A new take on doctor-patient confidentiality

Given that prescriptions are free to children under 16 and to those aged 16-18 in full-time education, could the government be persuaded to allow sanitary pads and tampons to be counted as an eligible prescription item? Then we could all contribute – through our taxes – to providing the funds to help girls get this most basic but important necessity (Letters, 22 March).
Jane Woddis
Birmingham

• Rather than suggesting My Ding-A-Ling was not “the real Chuck Berry” (Letters, 23 March), Mike Pender should celebrate it for what it is – Berry’s only properly British hit song for a nation brought up on innuendo under centuries of government censorship. The lord chamberlain’s rule had ended four years earlier in 1968, but an oddly shaped vegetable or a ding-a-ling still gets ’em going.
Mark Lewinski
Swaffham Prior, Cambridgeshire

• I’m a stranger to social media but even I know that Giles Fraser (Loose canon, 24 March) was a bit daft to think he could maintain a prayerful state of mind and keep up with Twitter at the same time.
Dr Brigid Purcell
Norwich

• Ian Mitchell writes that he lies to his doctor about how much he drinks (Letters, 24 March). I sometimes encounter my Hausarzt (GP) in a bar we favour, when we both quickly conceal our cigarettes under the table and pretend that the large glass of wine is our first. Any overt reference to our peccadilloes is met by him threatening a prostate examination.
Brian Smith
Berlin

• I wonder if Ian Mitchell’s GP reads the Guardian?
Tim Lidbetter
Kingston upon Thames, Surrey

• I’m pleased to assure Rev Philip Welsh that “anent” is part of my core vocabulary. I even use “aroint” occasionally, too.
Henry Malt
Huntingdon, Cambridgeshire

• Join the debate – email guardian.letters@theguardian.com

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit gu.com/letters

WhatsApp must be accessible to authorities, says Amber Rudd WhatsApp must be accessible to authorities, says Amber Rudd Why political rebels love WhatsApp

Amber Rudd has called for the police and intelligence agencies to be given access to WhatsApp and other encrypted messaging services to thwart future terror attacks, prompting opposition politicians and civil liberties groups to say her demand was unrealistic and disproportionate.

The home secretary said it was “completely unacceptable” that the government could not read messages protected by end-to-end encryption and said she had summoned leaders of technology companies to a meeting on Thursday 30 March to discuss what to do.

Speaking on the BBC’s Andrew Marr Show on Sunday, Rudd refused to rule out passing new legislation to tackle encrypted messaging if she did not get what she wanted.

But she stressed it was her desire to persuade internet and social media companies to cooperate voluntarily with the government on this and also the posting of extremist material online.

Rudd added: “It is completely unacceptable. There should be no place for terrorists to hide.

“We need to make sure that organisations like WhatsApp, and there are plenty of others like that, don’t provide a secret place for terrorists to communicate with each other.”

She indicated that she hoped to be able to win them over without resorting to legislation.

“These people __have families, __have children as well,” she said. “They should be on our side, and I’m going to try to win that argument.”

Her call came after it emerged that police were investigating reports that Khalid Masood, the British extremist who killed four people outside parliament before he was shot dead, had used WhatsApp a few minutes before he launched his attack on Wednesday.

Police have said they believe Masood was essentially a “lone actor”, though counter-terrorism officers continue to search for more details about his background and associations.

It emerged on Sunday that Masood had been on the radar of the intelligence community for potential links to extremism in 2010, after he returned from teaching English in Saudi Arabia.

A 30-year-old man was arrested in Birmingham on Sunday on suspicion of preparation of terrorist acts, making him the 12th person to be held over the incident. A 58-year-old man who was arrested in Birmingham on Thursday remained in police custody after his detention was extended under anti-terrorism legislation. All other people arrested in the aftermath of Masood’s attack have been released.

Critics questioned both the need for powers of the kind Rudd seemed to be demanding, and also the practicalities of trying to use UK domestic legislation to curb the activities of global internet companies largely based in the US.

Brian Paddick, the Liberal Democrat home affairs spokesman and a former deputy assistant commissioner in the Metropolitan police, said that giving the security services access to encrypted messages would be “neither a proportionate nor an effective response” to the Westminster attack.

“These terrorists want to destroy our freedoms and undermine our democratic society,” he said. “By implementing draconian laws that limit our civil liberties, we would be playing into their hands.

“My understanding is there are ways security services could view the content of suspected terrorists’ encrypted messages and establish who they are communicating with.”

Jeremy Corbyn, the Labour leader, said the police and intelligence services already had “huge, huge powers of investigation” and questioned Rudd’s demand.

He said he thought the balance in law between the interests of security and privacy was probably about right as it is.

Police and the security services have for some years expressed concerns about the ability of firms to provide messaging services using end-to-end encryption that means texts and emails cannot be accessed in extremis by the service provider, or by the authorities demanding information with a warrant.

But while encryption does make it much harder for the intelligence agencies to read messages, sources said one technique they could use to get around it was equipment interference, or hacking, which can enable spies to read what is on the screen of a phone that has been targeted.

The Open Rights Group, which campaigns for internet privacy, said Rudd’s proposal would make communications less secure for everyone online.

Its executive director, Jim Killock, said: “It is right that technology companies should help the police and intelligence agencies with investigations into specific crimes or terrorist activity where possible. This help should be requested through warrants and the process should be properly regulated and monitored.

“However, compelling companies to put back doors into encrypted services would make millions of ordinary people less secure online. We all rely on encryption to protect our ability to communicate, shop and bank safely.”

WhatsApp said in a statement that it was “horrified” by the London attack and that it was “cooperating with law enforcement”.

It is understood that Masood’s phone connected to WhatsApp shortly before he launched his attack on Westminster Bridge, but it is not known whether he sent or received a message.

At one point in an interview, Rudd appeared to say Masood had sent a message via WhatsApp, but the Home Office later said her words had been misconstrued and that she was only talking in general terms about terrorists sending WhatsApp messages.

Rudd also signalled a renewed determination to stop internet companies publishing extremist material online by declaring that they now had to accept they were “publishing companies”, with the responsibilities that went with that, not just technology firms providing a platform.